U.S. Frustrated by Israel’s Reluctance to Share Iran Retaliation Plans
Wall Street Journal-Oct9th2024
Israel has so far refused to divulge to the Biden administration details of its plans to retaliate against Tehran, U.S. officials said, even as the White House is urging its closest Middle East ally not to hit Iran’s oil facilities or nuclear sites amid fears of a widening regional war.
U.S. Officials are frustrated that they have been repeatedly caught off guard by Israel’s military actions in Gaza and Lebanon, and are seeking to head off further escalation. Some had hoped the U.S. would learn more about what Israel was contemplating during a planned meeting Wednesday between Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin at the Pentagon, but Gallant postponed his trip, the Pentagon said.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blocked Gallant from departing to the U.S. on Tuesday night as Israel continued planning its Iran operation, an Israeli official said. U.S. officials said they don’t yet have either the timing of the strike or what Israel might target.
President Biden and Netanyahu are planning to speak on the phone Wednesday, according to an Israeli official.
Last month, Israel carried out a strike against Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah without informing the U.S. ahead of time. The bombing, which took place as Washington was hoping to finalize a cease-fire plan between Israel and Lebanon, surprised senior administration officials.
“Excuse me, what did you say?” Austin said when Gallant told him during a call about the Nasrallah attack, according to U.S. officials familiar with the conversation. During a second call the same day, Austin asked Gallant if Israel was prepared to be “alone” when it came to defending itself, given the lack of notice.
Austin was frustrated because the U.S. didn’t have enough time to position its forces to potentially come to Israel’s defense or to protect nearby U.S. troops, defense officials said.
With Israel promising a response to Iran’s launching of nearly 200 missiles shortly after Nasrallah’s assassination, U.S. officials are hoping this time they will have more insights on a strike that could lead to greater American military involvement.
Israel has at times heeded U.S. advice over the past year. The U.S. sought a more deliberate plan to clear the southern Gaza city of Rafah, which prompted Israel to limit its operations there. The U.S. also persuaded Israel not to launch an attack on Hezbollah in Lebanon based on faulty intelligence just days after Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack.
But Israel’s response to Iran could test the limits of Israel’s responsiveness.